Data Catalog vs Data Inventory

You may think that a data catalog and a data inventory are the same thing, that they are interchangeable terms. With so many “data” terms being thrown around, it’s easy to get mixed up on what each tool does and how they are different. One thing is clear - both a data catalog and a data inventory are metadata management tools, but they are definitely not the same thing.

In today’s article, we’ll shine a light on each of these tools, explaining their similarities, differences, and benefits to modern, data-driven companies.

CastorDoc is your leading expert on all things data management, and our modern enterprise Data Catalog allows your whole team to find, understand, and trust your data.

Understanding Data Catalogs and Data Inventories

Let’s start from the beginning and gain a clear understanding of each of these tools and their distinct purposes.

What is a Data Catalog?

A data catalog is a tool that provides a centralized, searchable source of metadata within an organization. It includes information about all available data sources, datasets, databases, files, and other data sources. Ultimately, it allows users to find, understand, and use the data they need.

The primary purpose of a data catalog is to facilitate data discovery, understanding, and access for various stakeholders. A good catalog offers a searchable and user-friendly interface that enables users to explore the available data resources, gain insights into their structure, content, and relationships, and determine their suitability for specific use cases.

A data catalog encompasses various metadata associated with the data assets. This metadata typically includes descriptions, schemas, data lineage, access permissions, usage statistics, and information related to data governance and compliance.

A data catalog helps improve data discoverability, eliminate data silos, foster collaboration among data users, and enhance data governance and compliance. It enables organizations to make more informed decisions, accelerate data-driven initiatives, and maximize the value derived from their data resources.

What is a Data Inventory?

A data inventory is a comprehensive list or repository of data assets within an organization. It provides an overview of what data is available, where it is stored, and who owns it.

The main objective of a data inventory is to gain visibility into the organization's data assets and understand what data is available, where it is located, and how it is structured. It is a crucial tool for organizations to have in place in order to stay compliant with privacy protection regulations, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA).

Data inventory is required for compliance under Article 30 of the GDPR. This inventory must include: 

• Any personal data that an organization collects and uses
• Details about the location and method of storing this data
• Information on any data transformations

Similarly, the CCPA has data inventory requirements including information on: 

• Details of how personal data is being collected
• The personal data an organization has collected
• Where the data is being stored and its format
• Classes of data assets 

Being in violation of the CCPA or the GDPR can result in significant financial penalties and legal consequences, not to mention the potential reputational damage and loss of customer trust. The specific enforcement actions and penalties depend on the nature and severity of the violation. Therefore, it’s crucial for organizations to keep a well-organized data inventory to ensure compliance. 

By implementing robust data protection measures, conducting regular audits, and staying informed about changes in privacy laws, businesses can mitigate the risks and ensure they are on the right side of the law. This will safeguard both their reputation and their bottom line.

Differences Between Data Catalogs and Data Inventories

While data catalogs and data inventories sound similar, they have some important differences in purpose, functionality, and scope.

• Purpose: A data catalog focuses on facilitating data discovery and access, while a data inventory aims to create a comprehensive record of data assets for management and governance purposes.
• Functionality: A data catalog emphasizes search, exploration, and collaboration features, while a data inventory is more focused on capturing detailed information about data assets and identifying data dependencies and redundancies.
• Metadata: A data catalog handles a broader range of metadata, including data governance and usage information, while a data inventory primarily focuses on metadata specific to the data assets themselves.

According to the Federal CDO Council, “Data inventories are as essential to agencies as card catalogs are to libraries. These inventories make data assets discoverable to machines and humans.”

Some modern data catalogs, like CastorDoc, include data inventory capabilities, allowing organizations to have both catalog and inventory within a single platform.

The Evolution of Data Cataloging and Data Inventory

Over the years, data catalogs and data inventory tools have evolved significantly to meet the growing demands of managing and utilizing data effectively. Initially, these tools were primarily focused on providing metadata management capabilities, but they have now expanded to offer more advanced functionalities and integration with emerging technologies. 

It all started in the 1990s when IT teams were tasked with creating a giant inventory of data. This was a monumental task, and not without its complications. Some companies began offering metadata management tools, but setting these up was a major challenge.

As data volumes increased, the need for efficient data discovery emerged. During the 2000s, advancements in data catalog technology introduced search capabilities, enabling users to find and access data assets based on metadata attributes and keyword searches. 

In the 2010s, data catalogs evolved further by incorporating data profiling functionalities to assess data quality, completeness, and accuracy. Data lineage capabilities were also introduced to track the origins and transformations of data.

However, data catalogs struggled to keep up with the increasing size and diversity of the data stack, and this led to some of the large tech companies creating their own in-house catalog solutions. The most notable of these are LinkedIn’s DataHub and Lyft’s Amundsen.

Not every company had these kinds of resources. But in the 2020s, the modern data catalog 3.0 emerged - and this includes CastorDoc. CastorDoc is a comprehensive data catalog solution with embedded data inventory that can quickly integrate with your existing data stack.

The need for comprehensive data management has affected many different industries. Financial institutions need systems to manage regulatory compliance, risk analysis, and customer data privacy. In healthcare, data catalogs and inventories aid in managing patient records, medical research data, and compliance with privacy regulations. Retail industries need data catalog and inventory tools to manage customer data, sales records, and inventory information. 

The Future of Data Catalogs

When it comes to data catalogs, we can anticipate exciting developments in the future. As Artificial Intelligence (AI) continues to advance, we can expect to see more integration of AI technologies within data catalogs. AI can play a significant role in enhancing data discovery and cataloging processes by automating tasks such as data classification, metadata tagging, and data lineage tracking. This integration will not only streamline catalog management but also improve the accuracy and efficiency of data organization.

Additionally, as the regulatory environment surrounding data privacy continues to evolve, data catalogs will place an increasing emphasis on ensuring compliance with privacy regulations such as the CCPA and GDPR. Data catalogs will likely incorporate features that facilitate data governance and enable businesses to demonstrate transparency and accountability in handling personal and sensitive data. This may include functionalities like privacy impact assessments, data access controls, and privacy policy management.

The Importance of Both Data Catalogs and Data Inventories in Successful Data Management

It’s important to think not in terms of data catalog vs data inventory, but in terms of data catalog AND data inventory. Both are essential for successful data management.

If you think about it in simple terms, a data inventory provides data about your data. A data catalog provides even more data, but also allows for searchability, data discovery, collaboration, data management, and integration with your data stack. 

Having a comprehensive data catalog and inventory enables efficient data management processes. It helps in identifying redundant or obsolete data assets, streamlining data integration efforts, and minimizing data duplication. It also assists in assessing data quality and establishing data stewardship practices, ensuring that data is accurate, consistent, and reliable.

While a data inventory provides a basic overview of available data assets, a data catalog enriches it with metadata, context, searchability, and collaboration capabilities. Not having a data catalog can result in limited understanding, reduced discoverability, collaboration challenges, governance issues, and missed opportunities for data-driven innovation and decision-making.

Case Studies of Successful Data Management with Data Catalogs and Data Inventories

It’s helpful to look at data inventory use cases and how the combination of both inventory and catalog tools help companies overcome their data challenges. We’ll review two examples: Printify and Vestiaire Collective.

‍Printify, a growing online marketplace, had a large data inventory but experienced challenges when it came to data governance and collaboration. Filipe Palma, Data Platform Product Manager at Printify noted, “We had a lot of information in our data warehouse, but we were not offering context to our consumers on how to use it.” The lack of context and difficulty in finding relevant data hindered productivity. 

By selecting CastorDoc for its simplicity and search capabilities, stakeholders gained autonomy in accessing and leveraging data, resulting in decreased reliance on the data engineering team and improved productivity and decision-making. CastorDoc provided an automatic data inventory after ingesting data assets from the warehouse, and made that inventory searchable and understandable through its modern data catalog capabilities.

‍Vestiaire Collective, a global online marketplace for pre-loved fashion, faced major challenges in data documentation, context, and onboarding due to rapid growth. They sought a data catalog solution to automate documentation, provide rich context, and streamline onboarding. With CastorDoc, they automated documentation, reduced errors, and assigned data ownership. Vestiaire Collective estimated a 20% increase in team productivity since implementing CastorDoc.

From a data inventory perspective, Jimmy Pang, Business Intelligence Lead at Vestiaire Collective shared the specific benefits for onboarding: “With Castor’s data catalog, the on-boarded person now becomes fully independent and doesn't need a mentor to walk them through the company’s data assets.” The full data inventory is instantly available, as is the ability to navigate and understand it through the data catalog. This reduces onboarding time from a few weeks to barely two days.

How CastorDoc Can Help: Get Started with a Free 14-day Trial

CastorDoc is the premier solution for data-driven companies, offering an intuitive data catalog with embedded data inventory functionality. 

‍Our goal is clear - we’re here to make data more valuable by empowering everyone in the organization to make better decisions. CastorDoc places collaboration at its core, fostering an environment where teams can seamlessly share knowledge and engage in meaningful discussions about data assets.

CastorDoc seamlessly integrates with diverse data sources and management tools, offering an up-to-date and comprehensive catalog that provides a holistic view of your data landscape. With organized and easily accessible data assets, you can trust that your data is accurately represented, readily available, and easy to understand.

Experience the power of our platform firsthand with a 14-day free trial and unleash the full potential of your data assets. Sign up today and embark on a transformative data journey!

Subscribe to the Newsletter

About us

We write about all the processes involved when leveraging data assets: the modern data stack, data teams composition, and data governance. Our blog covers the technical and the less technical aspects of creating tangible value from data.

At Castor, we are building a data documentation tool for the Notion, Figma, Slack generation.

Or data-wise for the Fivetran, Looker, Snowflake, DBT aficionados. We designed our catalog software to be easy to use, delightful, and friendly.

Want to check it out? Reach out to us and we will show you a demo.